Implementation of Merit Systems in Border Regions: Anomalous Deconstruction and Spatial Meritocracy Model Formulation

merit system contingency theory spatial meritocracy talent retention 3t border area

Authors

November 18, 2026

Downloads

The universal application of the merit system often clashes with spatial particularities in vertical organizational units in marginalized areas. This study aims to analyze the implementation of the four main components of the merit system (formation planning, 20 JP competency development, promotion-mutation, and e-Performance), identify 3T sociogeographic barriers and vertical bureaucratic challenges, and formulate a model for MSDM governance mitigation at the Papua Merauke River Area Center (BWS). Using a qualitative approach with an instance case study method, data were collected through in-depth interviews, direct observation, and documentation studies. The results of the study show that the rigid national standardization that passes through the "Disruption Corridor" of the RI-PNG border gives birth to three empirical meritocratic anomalies:  the illusion of training compliance due to the compulsion of online training in the midst of the electricity-internet crisis, leniency bias in the form of performance value inflation for administrative formalities, and administrative helplessness due to centralization of central authorities. This accumulation of dysfunction has direct implications for the failure to retain new technical ASN talent (high turnover intention) and the chronic appointment of Acting Officials (Plt). As a contribution to novelty, this study recommends the Spatial Meritocracy Model, an affirmative policy formulation that integrates the decentralization of local management discretion with equitable fiscal spatial compensation to lock in the sustainability of talent in extreme border areas.